Caradigm Kills eHealth, Partners with Orion

Today, Caradigm and Orion Health announced their partnership wherein Caradigm will go to market with Orion Health’s HIE solution suite and likewise Orion Health will take ¬†Caradigm’s analytics solution, Caradigm Intelligence Platform (CIP) to market to its existing and future customers. Existing Caradigm customers (~20) who are now on the eHealth platform will be put on life-support and encouraged to make the transition to Orion’s solution in the coming year.

Orion Health has had a long relationship with Microsoft, including acquiring Microsoft’s Amalga HIS solution and partnering with Orion to combine the then Amalga UIS with Orion’s HIE solution. Shortly after this announcement was made though, Microsoft threw in the towel on the clinical market combining its assets with a collection of those from GE which resulted in the NewCo, Caradigm.

As part of the establishment of Caradigm, GE contributed eHealth, its HIE solution suite that was co-developed with Geisinger and Qualibria, a quality management platform developed in conjunction with InterMountain. With the death of eHealth and a product which has yet to see the light of day (Qualibria) its beginning to look like GE brought very little to the Caradigm relationship.

Back to the Orion-Caradigm partnership…

As we have written in the past the core services that HIE vendors offered in the past are quickly being commoditized by such things as Direct secure messaging being embedded in future certified EHRs for stage two meaningful use requirements. With the recent announcement of CommonWell Health Alliance, even query type services may also become commoditized.

Clearly, to stay competitive and relevant, HIE vendors need to move to what we term as HIE 2.0, providing more advanced services that leverage the data flowing through the “pipes” of an HIE to more effectively manage the health of a given community the HIE serves. This is particularly important for enterprise clients ( a market Orion is now targeting) and can also assist public HIEs (Orion’s traditional market) in providing value-add services that may help them reach nirvana (sustainability). With CIP, Orion can provide a more compelling offering. The big challenge here for Orion will be in effectively pricing and deploying CIP, (Amalga UIS was notoriously expensive and difficult to deploy. Caradigm has rebranded Amalga Version 3, a much improved version architecturally, as CIP to distance themselves from the stigma of the Amalga brand).

While the relationship provides value to Orion, it may provide even greater value to Caradigm, a company that has stumbled to gain traction in the market. Orion provides a ready channel to market via Orion’s existing broad HIE customer base – one of the world’s largest. Orion also provides Caradigm an effective exit from directly participating in the HIE market with a solution that frankly was not up to the task. The announcement also claims that Orion has agreed to develop applications for the CIP which contributes to Caradigm’s goal of being perceived as a platform play in the market. What those apps may be is still an open question. Based on the language in the PR, it looks like not a lot of thought has gone into that aspect of the relationship yet.

Now we’ll just have to wait and see how this plays out in the market.

What to watch:

  1. Joint customer wins – who and where.
  2. How many existing eHealth clients transition directly to Orion or jettison for another HIE vendor entirely.
  3. Apps that Orion builds for CIP.
  4. Existing Orion clients that purchase CIP and whether or not we see accelerated growth in such purchases or an initial surge followed by stagnation.
Both companies have something to gain in this relationship and will strive to make it work. But such partnerships can be extremely difficult to manage in the field. It will require close collaboration, a significant degree of trust and a willingness to give. Despite its large size and massive parents (MSFT & GE), Caradigm will need to give more to make this truly work.
Editor’s Note: A more in-depth deep dive into this partnership and its implications will be a part of our April Monthly Update that will be distributed to Chilmark Advisory Service clients.

 

 

Posted in ACO, Acquisition, Analytics, Connected Health, Health Information Exchange Tagged with: , , ,
6 comments on “Caradigm Kills eHealth, Partners with Orion
  1. John,
    I’m am the chairman of Jiff Inc. a software platform for the health care industry. The company is based in Palo Alto, CA, backed with $7.5M from Aberdare, Aeris Capital and me, and we’re doing very well with contracts with large insurers and self insured employers, adding about one employee per week. We’re about to launch publicly after being quiet for 18 months. We did some press 18 months ago in order to assist with the fund raising, but what is now left online is not representative of what we do. I’d love to connect by phone, tell you our story, and hear your thoughts. I am the former CEO of 3 venture backed companies, and finding the right language to describe a company when it first comes out is very important. If you have time, I think this is a story you will like…

  2. Very interesting analysis of the partnership. I think it’s a big win for Orion Health and says a lot about what they’ve built. Of course, this assumes that they’re able to get many customers to transition to Orion Health. I think they will do well though.

    • John says:

      Spoke with one of the GE eHealth customers who was actually quite excited about the partnership as they were getting ready to throw eHealth solution into the gutter anyway. Now they feel that they have a good path forward. One of the bigger questions will be how Caradigm and Orion actually go to market together. Pretty strange model today, eg Orion is not lead in Canada even though they have far greater presence than Caradigm. A lot of left over baggage stil to deal with.

  3. Jeff Brandt says:

    At first glance it seems like strange bedfellows, however this is the future of HIE and the Cloud or what I term the “UnEHR” http://www.blogger.com/blogger.g?blogID=5136740726167769418#editor/target=post;postID=4583478007144534683

    EHR are based on old tech, Old Iron, PCs and mainframes, the new unEHR will be mobile, Cloud based and connected via a Enterprise Service Bus, AKA, HIE. The HIE connect to a platform for delivering mobile APPS. The Apps talk to the Platform the HIE talks to the Cloud. Why do you need the EHR in the common form? The Network become the EHR ecosystem.

    • John says:

      Love the model Jeff and something I have been hoping for for sometime. Actually, what Orion did in Alberta is quite interesting. THe Province was to looking to put in a stop-gap solution until all physicians had adopted an EHR. Well guess what happened? The physicians started using Orion Health as the EHR as well and the Alberta HIE is arguably one of the most highly used HIEs in the world in terms of clinical information flow.

  4. S Willson says:

    Great analysis, enjoyed reading this post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Who We Are

Chilmark Research is the only industry analyst firm focusing solely on health IT. We combine proven research methodologies with intelligence and insight to provide cogent analyses of the emerging technologies that have the greatest potential to improve healthcare. We do not shy away from making tough calls, and are respected in the industry for our direct and thoughtful commentary.